Product comparison
The Farmer's Dog vs Ollie
Both are excellent fresh-food subscriptions. Farmer's Dog edges it on recipe simplicity and vet pedigree. Ollie wins on protein variety (turkey, beef, lamb, chicken) and their baked-recipe option for dogs who don't love wet food.
The Farmer's Dog
Ollie
Category
fresh food
fresh food
Tagline
Fresh, human-grade food portioned for your dog
Fresh food with both cooked and baked recipes
Highlights
Human-grade fresh food
Fresh and baked recipes
Portioned per dog
Turkey, beef, lamb, chicken proteins
Vet-developed recipes
Custom portions
50% off first box
60% off first box
Pick The Farmer's Dog if:
- ✓You want the most vet-backed option
- ✓Your dog does well with limited-ingredient simplicity
- ✓You value the freshest possible ingredients
Pick Ollie if:
- ✓Your dog needs protein variety or rotation
- ✓You want a baked (shelf-stable) option too
- ✓You're price-sensitive (Ollie is often slightly cheaper)
Barkly earns commissions on some links. This does not change our recommendation — we recommend based on fit, not commission rates.